Executive summary
- The UK's 100 largest contractors averaged a pre-tax margin of just over 3%, and a quarter made less than 2%. Construction accounted for 17% of company insolvencies in England and Wales in the year to August 2026, more than any other industry.
- Material prices rose 6.4% in the year to August 2026; tender prices rose 3.2%. Fixed-price work won a year ago is being built at this year's costs, so margin fades between tender and final account unless change is recovered.
- In the worked example below, £1.39m of a contractor's £4.06m forecast project margin — 34% — depends on variations the client hasn't agreed. That's the paper margin. With it, the business makes about 2.4% after overheads. Without it, 0.2%.
- The same contractor has £850k valued but not yet certified, and £1.02m held in retentions. Both are in the accounts as assets. Neither is cash, and only one of them is protected by a law that's coming.
Construction & property at DataHexis
"Project cost tracking, workforce analytics, valuation reports, and site performance." This piece is about where project cost tracking and valuation reports meet: the monthly reconciliation that tells a contractor what each job will really make.
— from the Industries section of the DataHexis websiteEvery month, a contractor's commercial team sits down with a cost report from the ledger and a valuation from the quantity surveyor, and agrees what each job will make. The number that comes out is the forecast margin, and the board treats it as a fact. It isn't one. It's a forecast built on cost not yet incurred and value not yet agreed.
Most of the time the two halves balance out. When they don't, the gap tends to show up late, at practical completion or at the final account, when the variations either get paid or don't. On a 9% tender margin that can be absorbed. On the 3% most contractors actually keep, one disputed account can be the year's profit.
Three pence in the pound
Construction is a high-turnover, thin-margin business, and the latest numbers haven't changed that. Recovery is real but modest: the listed contractors are reporting their best margins in years, and they're still under 4%.
Galliford Try's two divisions both reached 3.5% this year, with a target of 4% by 2030. The specialists in the Top 100 went the other way, from 3.69% to 3.33%. And the cost pressure hasn't eased: the government's materials price index for all work rose 6.4% in the year to August, while BCIS's tender price index rose 3.2%. Work priced last year is being built at this year's costs.
At a 3% margin, a contractor needs £33 of turnover to replace every £1 it doesn't recover.
Paper margin, defined
Forecast margin = forecast final value − forecast final cost. Final cost is cost to date plus accruals plus the cost to complete. Final value is the contract sum plus variations — agreed ones, and usually some that aren't agreed yet.
Paper margin is the part of the forecast margin that relies on value the client hasn't agreed: unagreed variations, compensation events still being priced, loss and expense not yet accepted. Secured margin is what's left if none of it is paid.
Including unagreed variations in the forecast isn't wrong. Under JCT a variation is valued after the event, and under NEC4 a compensation event is priced by quotation and can sit open for weeks. A commercial manager who left all of it out would understate every job. The issue is that most CVR packs show one blended number, so the board can't tell how much of the margin is earned and how much is still a negotiation.
The accounting rules are tightening in the same direction. The revised FRS 102 revenue section applies to periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, and it asks firms to assess variations and liquidated damages carefully, under the rules for contract modifications and variable consideration. In plain terms: the auditor will want to know which variations are agreed, which are likely, and on what evidence.
A variation in the forecast is a claim. A variation in the certificate is revenue.
Fade happens late, and is caused early
Margin fade is the gap between the margin a job was won at and the margin it finishes at. It's normal for margins to move as a job progresses. The problem is the pattern: forecasts tend to hold steady for months and then fall sharply near the end, because the cost of a delay or a design change is booked when it's incurred, while the matching variation stays in the forecast at full value until someone tells the commercial team it won't be paid.
That's why the secured margin is the more honest line to watch. It moves when the work goes wrong, not when the negotiation fails. On the care home in the worked example below, the reported forecast drifted from 8.5% to 4.9% over twelve monthly reconciliations. The secured margin fell to 2.1%, and it crossed the 5% minimum five months before the reported line did.
None of this needs a new idea. It needs the forecast kept month by month instead of overwritten, and the value side split by status. Most contractors' systems can hold both; most CVR spreadsheets don't.
Every month a forecast is overwritten, the evidence of fade is deleted with it.
Valued, certified, paid
Margin and cash are reconciled in different places. The quantity surveyor's internal valuation says what the work done is worth; the client's certificate says what they'll pay for now; the bank says what arrived. The gap between the first two is a contract asset in the accounts and a debate on site. The gap between the last two is the late payment the government has decided to legislate against.
Retentions are part of the same picture. In March 2026 the government said it would ban retentions in construction contracts, and the Commercial Payments Bill introduced in May proposes a two-year transition, after which retention clauses become void. Until then, retention is money a contractor has earned, holds as an asset, and can lose if the client fails. Knowing exactly how much is held, by job, and when each release falls due is the minimum.
Retention is margin you've already earned and haven't been allowed to keep.
A worked example: the live-jobs view
Here's what the reporting looks like for a regional building contractor in the North West with £58.6m of annual turnover and six live projects: education, health, a fit-out, a build-to-rent block, a care home and a warehouse. It's a composite of typical set-ups rather than a single client. The figures are illustrative, but they're calibrated against the benchmarks cited throughout, and every number reconciles to the others.
Three conventions apply throughout. Project margin is value less all project costs, including preliminaries, before head-office overheads of 4.3% of turnover. Forecast final value includes agreed variations and the commercial team's assessment of unagreed ones. Retention is 3%, half released at practical completion.
| Project | Contract | Complete | Tender margin | Forecast margin | Unagreed variations | Secured margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary school extension | JCT D&B | 86% | 9.0% | 6.6% | £140k | 4.7% |
| Health centre | NEC4 ECC A | 61% | 9.5% | 7.4% | £360k | 4.5% |
| Office fit-out | JCT MW | 95% | 11.0% | 9.8% | £30k | 9.2% |
| Build-to-rent, 96 flats | JCT D&B | 42% | 8.0% | 6.1% | £520k | 3.5% |
| Care home new build | JCT D&B | 72% | 8.5% | 4.9% | £290k | 2.1% |
| Distribution warehouse | NEC4 ECC A | 24% | 8.5% | 7.9% | £50k | 7.3% |
| All six | 8.8% | 6.7% | £1.39m | 4.5% |
Five sources feed the model:
The commercial director reviews this view at each month's CVR meeting; the finance director takes the same model to the bank. Each job's forecast is kept as a monthly snapshot, so fade is a line, not a memory.
Live jobs: six projects, £60.6m forecast value
September 2026 CVR · refreshed overnightThe two margin tiles sit at either end of the row on purpose. 6.7% is the forecast the commercial team believes; 4.5% is the floor if every open negotiation fails. Overheads are 4.3%. Every tile names its status in words as well as colour.
Cash due by project, next seven months (£k)
Built from each contract's due dates and the commercial team's valuation forecast, plus retention releases at practical completion. The fit-out and the school drop away by December; the warehouse and the flats carry the spring. The shape of next year's cash is visible now, while there's time to replace it.
Completion against paper margin: where each job sits
Early, little on paper: Distribution warehouse. Keep change notified and priced as it happens.
Late, little on paper: Office fit-out. Agree the final account and diarise the retention.
Early, heavily on paper: Health centre, Build-to-rent. The client still needs you on site. Use it.
Late, heavily on paper: School, Care home. Provide for what can't be evidenced, this month.
The bottom-right box is where margin fade comes from. The bottom-left box is where it can still be prevented, because a variation is easiest to agree while the client still needs the work finished.
The board view: five charts for the month-end pack
The CVR meeting goes job by job. The board needs the portfolio: how much of the forecast is secured, where fade is coming from, how far valuations are running ahead of certificates, and what each pound of turnover leaves behind. The same model answers all four.
Forecast project margin by job: secured and on paper
£4.06m forecast, of which £1.39m is on paper. Apply the forecast to the year's £58.6m turnover and the business makes about 2.4% after overheads — close to the Top 100's 3%. Take out the unagreed variations and it makes 0.2%. The difference between those two years is a set of variations nobody has signed.
Care home new build: forecast margin at each monthly CVR
The reported line stayed above the 5% minimum until the twelfth reconciliation. The secured line crossed it in month seven, when the frame delay was costed and the variation for it went into the forecast at full value. That's five months of warning the blended number didn't give.
Valued but not certified, by job
£850k in total, 2.4% of the value done to date. The build-to-rent block and the health centre carry over half of it. In the accounts it's a contract asset; on site, it's an argument still to be won.
Where each £1 of turnover goes
Sixty-two pence goes straight to subcontractors. That's why a specialist's late variation becomes the main contractor's fade: the cost is passed up the chain faster than the value is passed down it.
Applied for, and certified, by month
Clients certified 95.7% of what was applied for over six months. A steady gap is negotiation. A gap that widens on one job, month after month, is a valuation the client doesn't accept — and an early sign of paper margin.
Under the hood (for the data team)
The charts are the easy half. The work is getting a job-cost ledger, a folder of QS spreadsheets, a change register and a timesheet system to agree on what counts as a job, a cost code and a period.
Six tables and the monthly snapshotChange status, valuation stages, and why forecasts must never be overwritten
Everything lands in one small warehouse before Power BI sees it. Whichever ledger the business runs — Sage with a construction add-on, COINS, Business Central or another — it ends up in the same six tables:
| Table | Grain | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Fact Cost | Job × cost code × period | Actual cost, committed orders and accruals, kept separate so accruals can be reversed cleanly |
| Fact Valuation | Job × application × period | Applied, internally valued, certified, paid and retained — five numbers, not one |
| Fact Change | Variation or compensation event × status × date | Notified, submitted, agreed or rejected, with the value at each stage |
| Fact Forecast Snapshot | Job × cost code × CVR month | Cost to complete and final value as they stood at each month-end: the history of fade |
| Dim Job | Job, with contract form and terms | JCT or NEC, retention rate, payment cycle, practical completion date |
| Dim Cost Code | Cost code, mapped to a standard set | Subcontract, materials, labour, plant, preliminaries, so jobs can be compared |
The join that breaks first is the forecast. Most CVR spreadsheets are saved over each month, so last month's cost to complete is gone. Without the snapshot there's no fade line, only a final number and a story about how it happened.
The second is the change register. It usually lives in a separate spreadsheet per job, with different status words on each. Map them to four statuses before anything else, or "submitted" on one job and "with QS" on another will be counted differently.
The measuresSample DAX for forecast, paper and secured margin
Forecast Final Value =
SUM ( 'Job'[Contract Sum] )
+ CALCULATE ( SUM ( 'Change'[Assessed Value] ), 'Change'[Status] IN { "Agreed", "Submitted", "Notified" } )
Forecast Final Cost =
SUM ( 'Cost'[Actual] ) + SUM ( 'Cost'[Accrued] ) + SUM ( 'Forecast'[Cost to Complete] )
Forecast Margin = [Forecast Final Value] - [Forecast Final Cost]
Paper Margin =
CALCULATE ( SUM ( 'Change'[Assessed Value] ), 'Change'[Status] IN { "Submitted", "Notified" } )
Secured Margin % =
DIVIDE ( [Forecast Margin] - [Paper Margin], [Forecast Final Value] - [Paper Margin] )
Valued Not Certified =
SUM ( 'Valuation'[Internal Value to Date] ) - SUM ( 'Valuation'[Certified to Date] )
The detail that decides whether a commercial director trusts the number is in Paper Margin: it counts the assessed value of unagreed change, not its cost. If the cost of a delay is already in the forecast, removing the variation takes out exactly the margin that depends on it, so the secured figure is a true floor, not a double count.
Snapshot the forecast tables at each CVR sign-off, not at calendar month-end. If the reconciliation is signed on the 12th, the 30th's numbers are a different forecast, and fade measured between them is noise.
Already running CVR in your construction ERP?Where this adds something, and where it doesn't
The main construction systems now include CVR modules: cost and value side by side, cost to complete, applications and retentions. If every job runs through one of them, the QS valuations and the change register are kept in it too, and the forecast is snapshotted each month, you have most of what this article describes, and we'd tell you so.
The gap is usually at the edges. Valuations get done in a spreadsheet and keyed in as a single figure. The change register lives with the QS. Subcontractor applications arrive as PDFs. Timesheets and plant hire sit in other systems. Secured margin needs the change status, and cash needs the valuation stages, so the join is where the value is. That's what we build.
What we need, and what we don't
A finance director's first worry is usually commercial rather than personal data: tender prices and margins are sensitive. This reporting needs job-level cost and value, the change register, valuation and certificate figures, and labour hours by job. It doesn't need tender build-ups, bid strategy or client correspondence, and operatives' names in timesheets can be replaced with a reference before anything leaves your systems.
We sign a confidentiality agreement as well as a UK GDPR data processing agreement, act only as your processor, and keep the data on UK-hosted storage with named sub-processors. The reporting is read-only: it can't post to the ledger or issue a notice.
Specialist subcontractors and smaller builders
A specialist with a dozen jobs and a part-time QS doesn't need a warehouse, and we'd say so. It needs the same split a main contractor needs, kept in one sheet per job: what's applied for, what's certified, what's paid, and which variations are agreed. Most of the paper margin in the industry starts lower down the chain, in variations a specialist has done and not yet been paid for.
For a specialist, secured margin isn't a refinement; it's the whole question. The Top 100's specialists saw margins slip from 3.69% to 3.33% even as they grew. A specialist whose margin depends on two unagreed variations on one main contractor's job has its year in someone else's hands — and its retention there too, until the new law takes effect.
Frequently asked questions
What is a CVR in construction?
A cost value reconciliation compares the cost of the work on a job with the value earned for it, usually every month. It sets cost to date plus accruals against the valuation to date, then forecasts the final cost and final value to give a forecast margin. Done well, it keeps each month's forecast so changes can be traced, and separates agreed from unagreed variations.
What is margin fade in construction?
Margin fade is the gap between the margin a contract was won at and the margin it finally delivers. It usually comes from cost growth that isn't recovered: delays, design changes, productivity, price inflation and variations that don't get paid. It often appears late in a job because unagreed variations stay in the forecast at full value until they're rejected. Tracking the forecast month by month, with and without unagreed variations, shows it earlier.
What is a good profit margin for a UK construction company?
For context, the 2026 Top 100 contractors averaged a pre-tax margin of just over 3%, up from 2.4%, and a quarter made less than 2%. Among listed contractors, Kier reported a 3.9% adjusted operating margin for the year to June 2026, and Galliford Try's divisions reached 3.5%. Project margins before head-office overheads are higher; what matters is that they cover overheads with enough left once disputed variations are settled.
Are retentions being banned in the UK?
In March 2026 the government said it would ban retention payments in construction contracts, alongside a 60-day cap on payment terms and mandatory interest at 8% over base rate. The Commercial Payments Bill, introduced in May 2026, proposes a two-year transition before retention clauses become void. It's still going through Parliament, so check its progress before changing contract terms.
How should unagreed variations be treated in a CVR?
Most contractors include them in forecast final value at an assessed amount, which is reasonable if it's evidenced. The risk is reporting a single blended margin. Show the margin with and without unagreed change, age the variations by status, and agree a policy with your accountant: the revised FRS 102 revenue rules, effective for periods from 1 January 2026, require variations to be assessed under the rules for contract modifications and variable consideration.
Sources
- The Construction Index, Top 100 construction companies 2026, with Company Watch (average pre-tax margin just over 3%, from 2.4%; 13 loss-making; a quarter below 2%; Top 20 specialists 3.69% to 3.33%). theconstructionindex.co.uk
- Kier Group, Results for the year ended 30 June 2026, 15 September 2026 (adjusted operating margin 3.9%). investegate.co.uk
- Galliford Try, Final results, 17 September 2026 (Building and Infrastructure divisional margins 3.5%; 2030 target 4.0%). investegate.co.uk
- Federation of Master Builders, SME construction survey, 31 March 2026 (493 firms; 51% lower-than-expected profits or losses; 20% viability under threat). fmb.org.uk
- Insolvency Service, Company insolvencies August 2026: commentary, 18 September 2026 (construction 3,866 cases, 17%). gov.uk
- BCIS, Latest construction materials prices (DBT data), October 2026 (all work up 6.4% in the 12 months to August 2026). bcis.co.uk
- BCIS five-year forecast, reported by Specification Online, 30 June 2026 (tender price index up 3.2% in 2Q2026). specificationonline.co.uk
- GOV.UK, Time to pay up: government unveils toughest crackdown on late payments in over 25 years, 24 March 2026. gov.uk
- Osborne Clarke, Commercial Payments Bill would ban retention and late payments in UK construction, 18 June 2026. osborneclarke.com
- Moore Kingston Smith, Key changes to FRS 102 revenue recognition for construction businesses, 1 April 2026. mooreks.co.uk
Related reading
How much of your margin is on paper?
In a free 60-minute discovery call, we'll look at where your cost ledger, valuations, change register and timesheets live, and tell you what a monthly secured-margin view would take. Or start with our fixed-price CVR Health Check, from £750, credited in full against any build.
Book a free discovery call → No tender build-ups needed · Delivered by a partner · First dashboard usually within about two weeks